The Spanish authority declares a GDPR infringement for the Santa Brígida town hall regarding excessive video surveillance

The Spanish data protection authority has issued a sanction decision against the Santa Brígida town hall, not in the form of a fine but as a declaration of infringement, for breaches related to the data minimisation principle in the context of the use of video surveillance systems in several of its buildings.

Facts and context

The case originated from a complaint by an individual on August 31, 2024, reporting the installation of cameras in several municipal buildings without adequate information and questioning the legitimacy of the processing, particularly concerning the protection of workers' and citizens' rights.

Reasons for the decision

The authority found a main breach against the town hall:

  • Data minimisation obligation (Article 5(1)(c) of the GDPR): The authority observed that the field of view of several cameras installed in the library, the elderly center, the youth space, and an exhibition room was excessive in relation to the invoked security purpose. Relying on Recital 39 of the GDPR, it judged that capturing areas such as reading desks, computer screens, meeting tables, or relaxation spaces was neither adequate, relevant, nor limited to what is strictly necessary to prevent theft or vandalism. Even after corrective measures announced by the town hall, the analysis showed that four cameras continued to film irrelevant areas, thus violating the minimisation principle.

Authority's decision

Consequently, the authority declared that the Santa Brígida town hall infringed Article 5(1)(c) of the GDPR, applying the specific regime for public administrations provided by Spanish legislation which allows declaring an infringement without necessarily imposing a fine.

Furthermore, the authority ordered the town hall to demonstrate, within three months, that the field of view of the four still non-compliant cameras (two in the library, one in the elderly center, and one in the exhibition room) complies with the data minimisation principle.

Lessons learned

This decision reminds that:

  • The security purpose for property and persons does not justify generalized and panoramic surveillance of spaces, notably workstations, reading areas, or relaxation places, whose capture must be strictly limited to what is necessary.
  • Bringing a video surveillance system into compliance requires a concrete analysis of the field of view of each camera; simple reorientations or partial deactivations may be insufficient if irrelevant areas remain captured.
  • Reserving the possibility to reactivate cameras exceptionally in the presence of indications of unlawful acts does not constitute a sufficient corrective measure to remedy an established violation of the minimisation principle.

Informations complémentaires

L'analyse complète est réservée aux membres

Montant de la sanction, thèmes, secteurs, entités et données concernées : l'essai gratuit de 14 jours ouvre la fiche entière et la veille personnalisée.

Essayer gratuitement 14 jours · accès complet · sans carte bancaire