The Polish authority sanctions a private school for illegal video surveillance in classrooms

The Polish data protection authority (UODO) sanctioned a private school for the use of video surveillance in classrooms, deeming this practice disproportionate and lacking a legal basis, in the absence of a prior risk assessment for the privacy of students.

Facts and context

The Polish data protection authority (UODO) issued a sanction decision against the private primary school "SOKRATES" (including the imposition of a fine of 52,511 zł (approximately €12,200)) for breaches related to the use of a video surveillance system in its classrooms.

The decision follows an administrative procedure initiated after an inspection conducted by the authority at the school's premises to verify the compliance of its video surveillance system, in place since 2007 and never reassessed.

Grounds for the decision

  • Lawfulness obligation of processing (Article 6(1) of the GDPR): The school justified the surveillance by security imperatives, invoking its legitimate interest. The authority found that the school did not demonstrate any valid legal basis for this processing. It considered that continuous surveillance in classrooms was an excessively intrusive measure regarding the privacy of minor students. The authority emphasized that the security objective could have been achieved by less invasive means, such as hiring surveillance personnel, which were not considered by the institution.
  • Security obligation of processing (Article 32(1) and (2) of the GDPR): The school did not carry out a risk assessment related to the use of video surveillance, wrongly assuming that the absence of daily consultation of recordings meant no risk. The authority recalled that data processing includes collection, storage, and deletion, and that the continuous operation of cameras constituted processing. This lack of assessment prevented the school from implementing appropriate technical and organizational measures to ensure a security level appropriate to the risk, especially for data concerning minors.
  • Obligation to regulate subcontracting (Article 28 of the GDPR): The contract concluded with an external IT technician for the maintenance of the surveillance system did not comply with GDPR requirements. The subcontracting agreement was incomplete as it did not specifically cover processing operations related to video surveillance, such as access to recordings and making copies, which were nevertheless performed by the provider on behalf of the school.

Authority's decision

Consequently, the authority imposed a fine of 52,511 zł (approximately €12,200) on the private primary school "SOKRATES" for the breach of Article 6(1) of the GDPR.

Furthermore, the authority ordered the school to bring its video surveillance processing operations into compliance with the GDPR within 14 days. It also issued a warning for violations of Articles 28 and 32 of the GDPR, to encourage the school to conduct a proper risk assessment and implement adequate security measures.

Lessons learned

This decision reminds that:

  • Pursuing a legitimate interest, such as the security of persons and property, must be balanced against the rights and freedoms of the data subjects and cannot justify continuous and intrusive surveillance, especially when it targets minors in a school setting.
  • The deployment of a video surveillance system must imperatively be preceded by a risk assessment to evaluate the necessity and proportionality of the system, consider less intrusive alternative measures, and define appropriate security measures.
  • The notion of "processing" is broad and covers passive operations such as mere data storage; the absence of active consultation of recordings does not reduce the obligations of the controller regarding security and lawfulness.

Informations complémentaires

L'analyse complète est réservée aux membres

Montant de la sanction, thèmes, secteurs, entités et données concernées : l'essai gratuit de 14 jours ouvre la fiche entière et la veille personnalisée.

Essayer gratuitement 14 jours · accès complet · sans carte bancaire