The Court of Justice confirms the inadmissibility of the European Data Protection Supervisor's action against the amendment of the Europol regulation
The Court of Justice of the European Union ruled inadmissible the appeal of the European Data Protection Supervisor, considering that the amendment of the Europol regulation did not directly affect its legal situation nor undermine its prerogatives or independence.
Facts and context
The Court of Justice of the European Union, by a judgment of 17 November 2026, confirmed the inadmissibility of the annulment action brought by the European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) against an amendment to the Europol regulation.
The case originated from a decision by the EDPS ordering the European Union Agency for Law Enforcement Cooperation (Europol) to categorize or, failing that, erase personal data stored in violation of Union law. Faced with a subsequent legislative amendment authorizing, on a transitional basis, the continued processing of this data, the EDPS considered that these new provisions undermined its independence and rendered its decision ineffective, and requested its annulment.
Reasons for the decision
The reasoning of the Court of Justice is based on the inadmissibility of the appeal due to the EDPS's lack of standing:
- Lack of standing: The Court recalled that, unlike Union institutions, the EDPS must demonstrate its standing. To do so, it must prove that the contested legislative provisions concern it directly and individually. However, the Court found that the transitional provisions adopted had no effect on the nature or scope of the tasks entrusted to the EDPS. They did not modify its rights, obligations, or powers, nor did they alter the guarantees of its independence. Furthermore, they did not annul the decision the EDPS had taken against Europol. Consequently, the contested provisions did not directly affect the EDPS's legal situation, which led the General Court, then the Court, to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Decision of the authority
Consequently, the Court of Justice confirmed the General Court's ruling and declared the EDPS's appeal inadmissible.
Lessons learned
This decision recalls that:
- The capacity of a supervisory authority, including the EDPS, to challenge a Union legislative act is subject to demonstrating standing, implying that the act affects it directly and individually in its legal situation.
- A new legislative provision that modifies the legal framework applicable to a controller does not necessarily constitute a direct infringement of a supervisory authority's prerogatives, even if it impacts the practical effects of a prior decision by that authority.
- The independence of a supervisory authority is not considered compromised by a legislative amendment that does not modify its powers, rights, or obligations, but adjusts the substantive rules applicable to data processing.
Informations complémentaires
L'analyse complète est réservée aux membres
Montant de la sanction, thèmes, secteurs, entités et données concernées : l'essai gratuit de 14 jours ouvre la fiche entière et la veille personnalisée.
Essayer gratuitement 14 jours · accès complet · sans carte bancaire