The Court of Justice of the European Union interprets Directive 2002/58 on protection against unsolicited commercial calls: this also concerns calls to persons acting for professional purposes, including sole proprietors

The Court of Justice of the European Union has ruled on the interpretation of Directive 2002/58/EC concerning protection against unsolicited commercial calls, following a dispute regarding the validity of a contract concluded by telephone solicitation with a sole proprietor.

Referred by the Regional Court of Saarbrücken in Germany, the case concerns a freelance translator contacted by phone without her prior consent by the company Firmenauskunft P.U.R. GmbH, which operates a professional directory. A paid registration contract amounting to 3,570 euros was concluded during this call. The referring court questions the compatibility of national law with Directive 2002/58, as German legislation, although qualifying the call as unlawful, does not necessarily consider the resulting contract null nor its conclusion as compensable damage. This situation might not be sufficiently deterrent for companies using this type of solicitation.

The Court (Fourth Chamber) held that Article 13(3) and the first sentence of Article 13(5) of Directive 2002/58/EC must be interpreted as meaning that the protection of privacy against unsolicited communications made for direct marketing purposes, in cases other than those referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2 of this Article 13,

– extends to all users and subscribers of a publicly accessible electronic communications service who are natural persons acting for professional purposes,

– opposes such unsolicited communications being made to natural persons acting for professional purposes, either where the subscriber or user has not given prior consent or where the subscriber or user has expressed refusal to receive such communications, according to the choice of the national legislator, and

– does not require Member States, in order to ensure the effectiveness of Article 13(3) and the first sentence of Article 13(5), to ensure that the natural person who has received an unsolicited communication is able to invoke the invalidity of a contract concluded by "surprise effect" following such communication or to obtain compensation for damage caused by the execution of such a contract.

Informations complémentaires

L'analyse complète est réservée aux membres

Montant de la sanction, thèmes, secteurs, entités et données concernées : l'essai gratuit de 14 jours ouvre la fiche entière et la veille personnalisée.

Essayer gratuitement 14 jours · accès complet · sans carte bancaire