The Belgian authority sanctions an association for non-compliance with the right to erasure and shortcomings in technical measures in direct marketing

The Belgian Data Protection Authority reprimanded an association which, despite repeated confirmations, had not effectively erased a person's data from its mailing lists, thus illustrating a failure of appropriate technical and organizational measures.

Facts and context

The Data Protection Authority (DPA) issued a decision against a non-profit association for breaches related to non-compliance with a request for erasure and the continued sending of commercial communications.

The case originated from a complaint by an individual who continued to receive commercial solicitations despite their request for data erasure, confirmed by the organization.

Grounds for the decision

  • Obligation to respect the right to erasure (Article 17 of the GDPR): The authority found that the organization had not erased the complainant's data within the required timeframe after the individual objected to processing for marketing purposes, violating their right to erasure. Although the organization confirmed deletion on 22 January 2024, the subsequent and repeated sending of commercial communications (notably on 9 April 2024, 14 June 2024, and even up to 30 May 2025) demonstrated that the request had not been fully implemented. The authority analyzed this breach with regard to Article 17(1)(c) of the GDPR, together with Article 12 of the GDPR concerning modalities for exercising rights.
  • Obligation to ensure the accountability of the controller (Article 24 of the GDPR): The contentious chamber considered that the persistent non-compliance with the erasure request revealed a failure of appropriate technical and organizational measures. The fact that the complainant's contact details remained in a file linked to the Mailchimp email marketing tool, despite their deletion from the main database, was considered an organizational failure. This breach of the obligation to ensure and demonstrate compliance, relying notably on Recital 78 of the GDPR, constitutes a violation of the accountability obligation, which includes data protection by design (Article 25 of the GDPR) and the ability to demonstrate compliance (Article 5(2) of the GDPR).

Decision of the authority

Consequently, the authority did not impose an administrative fine, taking into account that it was a first offense, the association's limited resources, and its dependence on donations.

Furthermore, the authority ordered the organization to erase all personal data of the complainant not necessary for compliance with a legal obligation. It also instructed it to bring its data processing into compliance with the GDPR and to provide proof of the corrective measures announced within one month.

Lessons learned

This decision reminds that:

  • confirmation of an erasure request engages the responsibility of the controller, who must ensure its effective impact across all systems, including third-party tools such as email sending platforms;
  • deletion of data in a main system (such as customer relationship management software) is insufficient if copies or subsets of that data persist in ancillary applications or files used for specific processing such as marketing;
  • a single breach of an individual right may be considered by a supervisory authority as a symptom of a broader failure in technical and organizational measures, engaging the controller's responsibility under Article 24 of the GDPR.

Informations complémentaires

L'analyse complète est réservée aux membres

Montant de la sanction, thèmes, secteurs, entités et données concernées : l'essai gratuit de 14 jours ouvre la fiche entière et la veille personnalisée.

Essayer gratuitement 14 jours · accès complet · sans carte bancaire